Brokers with "No Requoting" @ Forex Factory

What does No Slippage in Forex really mean? – Forex Markets Live

fintech #trading #algotrading #quantitative #quant #forex #fx #strategies #marketmaking

What does No Slippage in Forex really mean? – Forex Markets Live Slippage in Forex is when a non-limit order isn’t executed at the intended price. This is usually happening during times of high volatility and often during a news event. This would indicate a market condition and probably something that a Forex Broker has little control over. Then why do so many Forex Brokers make a claim they offer no slippage? No Slippage has become a marketable phrase used by brokers like ECN or STP.
In the United States, Forex Brokers are prohibited from claiming no slippage unless they can demonstrate that all orders on its platform were executed at the original price and no requotes were given. US Brokers are also prohibited from making any price adjustments ever if they want to make this claim. The fact that regulators in the US saw how much these claims were being made and instituted this rule back in 2012.
Some brokers are very transparent about slippage and the fact that they have little.....
Continue reading at: https://forexmarketslive.com/what-does-no-slippage-in-forex-really-mean/
submitted by silahian to quant_hft [link] [comments]

[Not my post] The Structure of Forex Brokers

Originally posted by Darkstar at Forex Factory.
Disclaimer: I did not write this. I found this post on ForexFactory written by a user called DarkStar, which I believe a lot of redditors will benefit from reading.
________________________________________________________________________________________________________
There has been much discussion of late regarding borker spreads and liquidity. Many assumptions are being made about why spreads are widened during news time that are built on an incomplete knowledge of the architecture of the forex market in general. The purpose of this article is to dissect the market and hopefully shed some light on the situation so that a more rational and productive discussion can be undertaken by the Forex Factory members.
We will begin with an explanation of the purpose of the Forex market and how it is utilized by its primary participants, expand into the structure and operation of the market, and conclude with the implications of this information for speculators. With that having been said, let us begin.
Unlike the various bond and equity markets, the Forex market is not generally utilized as an investment medium. While speculation has a critical role in its proper function, the lion’s share of Forex transactions are done as a function of international business.
The guy who buys a shiny new Eclipse more then likely will pay for it with US Dollars. Unfortunately Mitsubishi’s factory workers in Japan need to get their paychecks denominated in Yen, so at some point a conversion needs to be made. When one considers that companies like Exxon, Boeing, Sony, Dell, Honda, and thousands of other international businesses move nearly every dollar, real, yen, rubble, pound, and euro they make in a foreign country through the Forex market, it isn’t hard to understand how insignificant the speculative presence is; even in a $2tril per day market.
By and large, businesses don’t much care about the intricacies of exchange rates, they just want to make and sell their products. As a central repository of a company’s money, it was only natural that the banks would be the facilitators of these transactions. In the old days it was easy enough for a bank to call a foreign bank (or a foreign branch of ones own bank) and swap the stockpiles of currency each had accumulated from their many customers.
Just as any business would, the banks bought the foreign currency at one rate and marked it up before selling it to the customer. With that the foreign exchange spread was born. This was (and still is) a reasonable cost of doing business. Mitsubishi can pay its customers and the banks make a nice little profit for the hassle and risks associated with moving around the currency.
As a byproduct of transacting all this business, bank traders developed the ability to speculate on the future of currency rates. Utilizing a better understanding of the market, a bank could quote a business a spread on the current rate but hold off hedging until a better one came along. This process allowed the banks to expand their net income dramatically. The unfortunate consequence was that liquidity was redistributed in a way that made certain transactions impossible to complete.
It was for this reason and this reason alone that the market was eventually opened up to non-bank participants. The banks wanted more orders in the market so that a) they could profit from the less experienced participants, and b) the less experienced participants could provide a better liquidity distribution for execution of international business hedge orders. Initially only megacap hedge funds (such as Soros’s and others) were permitted, but it has since grown to include the retail brokerages and ECNs.

Market Structure:
Now that we have established why the market exists, let’s take a look at how the transactions are facilitated:
The top tier of the Forex market is transacted on what is collectively known as the Interbank. Contrary to popular belief the Interbank is not an exchange; it is a collection of communication agreements between the world’s largest money center banks.
To understand the structure of the Interbank market, it may be easier to grasp by way of analogy. Consider that in an office (or maybe even someone’s home) there are multiple computers connected via a network cable. Each computer operates independently of the others until it needs a resource that another computer possesses. At that point it will contact the other computer and request access to the necessary resource. If the computer is working properly and its owner has given the requestor authorization to do so, the resource can be accessed and the initiating computers request can be fulfilled. By substituting computers for banks and resources for currency, you can easily grasp the relationships that exist on the Interbank.
Anyone who has ever tried to find resources on a computer network without a server can appreciate how difficult it can be to keep track of who has what resources. The same issue exists on the Interbank market with regard to prices and currency inventory. A bank in Singapore may only rarely transact business with a company that needs to exchange some Brazilian Real and it can be very difficult to establish what a proper exchange rate should be. It is for this purpose that EBS and Reuters (hereafter EBS) established their services.
Layered on top (in a manner of speaking) of the Interbank communication links, the EBS service enables banks to see how much and at what prices all the Interbank members are willing to transact. Pains should be taken to express that EBS is not a market or a market maker; it is an application used to see bids and offers from the various banks.
The second tier of the market exists essential within each bank. By calling your local Bank of America branch you can exchange any foreign currency you would like. More then likely they will just move some excess currency from one branch to another. Since this is a micro-exchange with a single counterparty, you are basically at their mercy as to what exchange rate they will quote you. Your choice is to accept their offer or shop a different bank. Everyone who trades the forex market should visit their bank at least once to get a few quotes. It would be very enlightening to see how lucrative these transactions really are.
Branching off of this second tier is the third tier retail market. When brokers like Oanda, Forex.com, FXCM, etc. desire to establish a retail operation the first thing they need is a liquidity provider. Nine in ten of these brokers will sign an agreement with just one bank. This bank will agree to provide liquidity if and only if they can hedge it on EBS inclusive of their desired spread. Because the volume will be significantly higher a single bank patron will transact, the spreads will be much more competitive. By no means should it be expected these tier 3 providers will be quoted precisely what exists on the Interbank. Remember the bank is in the business of collecting spreads and no agreement is going to suspend that priority.
Retail forex is almost akin to running a casino. The majority of its participants have zero understanding how to trade effectively and as a result are consistent losers. The spread system combined with a standard probability distribution of returns gives the broker a built in house advantage of a few percentage points. As a result, they have all built internal order matching systems that play one loser off against a winner and collect the spread. On the occasions when disequilibrium exists within the internal order book, the broker hedges any exposure with their tier 2 liquidity provider.
As bad as this may sound, there are some significant advantages for speculators that deal with them. Because it is an internal order book, many features can be provided which are otherwise unavailable through other means. Non-standard contract sizes, high leverage on tiny account balances, and the ability to transact in a commission free environment are just a few of them…
An ECN operates similar to a Tier 2 bank, but still exists on the third tier. An ECN will generally establish agreements with several tier 2 banks for liquidity. However instead of matching orders internally, it will just pass through the quotes from the banks, as is, to be traded on. It’s sort of an EBS for little guys. There are many advantages to the model, but it is still not the Interbank. The banks are going to make their spread or their not go to waste their time. Depending on the bank this will take the form of price shading or widened spreads depending on market conditions. The ECN, for its trouble, collects a commission on each transaction.
Aside from the commission factor, there are some other disadvantages a speculator should consider before making the leap to an ECN. Most offer much lower leverage and only allow full lot transactions. During certain market conditions, the banks may also pull their liquidity leaving traders without an opportunity to enter or exit positions at their desired price.

Trade Mechanics:
It is convenient to believe that in a $2tril per day market there is always enough liquidity to do what needs to be done. Unfortunately belief does not negate the reality that for every buyer there MUST be a seller or no transaction can occur. When an order is too large to transact at the current price, the price moves to the point where open interest is abundant enough to cover it. Every time you see price move a single pip, it means that an order was executed that consumed (or otherwise removed) the open interest at the current price. There is no other way that prices can move.
As we covered earlier, each bank lists on EBS how much and at what price they are willing to transact a currency. It is important to note that no Interbank participant is under any obligation to make a transaction if they do not feel it is in their best interest. There are no “market makers” on the Interbank; only speculators and hedgers.
Looking at an ECN platform or Level II data on the stock market, one can get a feel for what the orders on EBS look like. The following is a sample representation:
You’ll notice that there is open interest (Level II Vol figures) of various sizes at different price points. Each one of those units represents existing limit orders and in this example, each unit is $1mil in currency.
Using this information, if a market sell order was placed for 38.4mil, the spread would instantly widen from 2.5 pips to 4.5 pips because there would no longer be any orders between 1.56300 and 1.56345. No broker, market maker, bank, or thief in the night widened the spread; it was the natural byproduct of the order that was placed. If no additional orders entered the market, the spread would remain this large forever. Fortunately, someone somewhere will deem a price point between those 2 figures an appropriate opportunity to do something and place an order. That order will either consume more interest or add to it, depending whether it is a market or limit order respectively.
What would have happened if someone placed a market sell order for 2mil just 1 millisecond after that 38.4 mil order hit? They would have been filled at 1.5630 Why were they “slipped”? Because there was no one to take the other side of the transaction at 1.56320 any longer. Again, nobody was out screwing the trader; it was the natural byproduct of the order flow.
A more interesting question is, what would happen if all the listed orders where suddenly canceled? The spread would widen to a point at which there were existing bids and offers. That may be 5,7,9, or even 100 pips; it is going to widen to whatever the difference between a bid and an offer are. Notice that nobody came in and “set” the spread, they just refused to transact at anything between it.
Nothing can be done to force orders into existence that don’t exist. Regardless what market is being examined or what broker is facilitating transactions, it is impossible to avoid spreads and slippage. They are a fact of life in the realm of trading.

Implications for speculators:
Trading has been characterized as a zero sum game, and rightly so. If trader A sells a security to trader B and the price goes up, trader A lost money that they otherwise could have made. If it goes down, Trader A made money from trader B’s mistake. Even in a huge market like the Forex, each transaction must have a buyer and a seller to make a trade and one of them is going to lose. In the general realm of trading, this is materially irrelevant to each participant. But there are certain situations where it becomes of significant importance. One of those situations is a news event.
Much has been made of late about how it is immoral, illegal, or downright evil for a broker, bank, or other liquidity provider to withdraw their order (increasing the spread) and slip orders (as though it was a conscious decision on their part to do so) more then normal during these events. These things occur for very specific reasons which have nothing to do with screwing anyone. Let us examine why:
Leading up to an economic report for example, certain traders will enter into positions expecting the news to go a certain way. As the event becomes immanent, the banks on the Interbank will remove their speculative orders for fear of taking unnecessary losses. Technical traders will pull their orders as well since it is common practice for them to avoid the news. Hedge funds and other macro traders are either already positioned or waiting until after the news hits to make decisions dependent on the result.
Knowing what we now know, where is the liquidity necessary to maintain a tight spread coming from?
Moving down the food chain to Tier 2; a bank will only provide liquidity to an ECN or retail broker if they can instantly hedge (plus their requisite spread) the positions on Interbank. If the Interbank spreads are widening due to lower liquidity, the bank is going to have to widen the spreads on the downstream players as well.
At tier 3 the ECN’s are simply passing the banks offers on, so spreads widen up to their customers. The retailers that guarantee spreads of 2 to 5 pips have just opened a gaping hole in their risk profile since they can no longer hedge their net exposure (ever wonder why they always seem to shut down or requote until its over?). The variable spread retailers in turn open up their spreads to match what is happening at the bank or they run into the same problems fixed spreads broker are dealing with.
Now think about this situation for a second. What is going to happen when a number misses expectations? How many traders going into the event with positions chose wrong and need to get out ASAP? How many hedge funds are going to instantly drop their macro orders? How many retail traders’ straddle orders just executed? How many of them were waiting to hear a miss and executed market orders?
With the technical traders on the sidelines, who is going to be stupid enough to take the other side of all these orders?
The answer is no one. Between 1 and 5 seconds after the news hits it is a purely a 1 way market. That big long pin bar that occurs is a grand total of 2 prices; the one before the news hit and the one after. The 10, 20, or 30 pips between them is called a gap.
Is it any wonder that slippage is in evidence at this time?

Conclusions:
Each tier of the Forex market has its own inherent advantages and disadvantages. Depending on your priorities you have to make a choice between what restrictions you can live with and those you cant. Unfortunately, you can’t always get what you want.
By focusing on slippage and spreads, which are the natural byproduct of order flow, one is not only pursuing a futile ideal, they are passing up an enormous opportunity to capitalize on true inefficiencies. News events are one of the few times where a large number of players are positioned inappropriately and it is fairly easy to profit from their foolishness. If a trader truly wants to make the leap to the next level of profitability they should be spending their time figuring out how identify these positions and trading with the goal of capturing the price movement they inevitably will cause.
Nobody is going to make the argument that a broker is a trader’s best friend, but they still provide a valuable service and should be compensated for their efforts. By accepting a broker for what it is and learning how to work within the limitations of the relationship, traders have access to a world of opportunity that they otherwise could never dream of capturing. Let us all remember that simple truth.
submitted by Cross_Game to Forex [link] [comments]

ROFX.Group

ROFX.Group
https://preview.redd.it/6q30gbl8ikn11.jpg?width=1200&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=5522d29a7b2159e73f5612f871f86e9ae43c38aa
Presuming that you have gone through all the basic requirements of what is needed to be a successful forex trader and found that you do not meet any, does that means it’s the end of your investment chances? Of course not because there is a service that lets even the novice and unrefined forex traders invest in the market without the slightest background in it. The ROFX.group for forex trading service will let you invest in this rewarding market with so much simplicity and flexibility that you do not need to do much other than wait for your profits. Beginners finally do not need to invest much mental work into choosing the right broker, installing the right software and trade. You finally do not need to begin the demo trading journey and learn all the details of money management, pair selection and correlation that beginner traders have to go through. This service just lets you invest a certain amount of money and have your profits remitted to you after a team of forex experts working with an AI system have done all the work. You know what that means? Your money grows in a stable and rewarding arrangement and still offers you a guarantee that your money will not shrink. The service offers profits of about 0.5% on average daily.
Artificial Intelligence in a different way
Artificial Intelligence aids with a lot of processes that would take a lot of time to do manually. Lately, these robots can even figure out some patterns that a human eye may have ignored or was just not aware of its existence and meaning. The ROFX.group robot is run by proven forex traders and other scientists who keep on updating its code with the newest trade-sensitive information to ensure that all clients only get the best of the market. You can go on with your business having the confidence that the team will work together to pick the optimal trades and leave out the potential bad eggs that have a high chance of ending up as losing trades.
AI is supervised by an experienced group of in-house forex traders
The AI system has been in operation for almost 10 years and it simply builds on the store of experience that the current team has had through the years. Having an operation style that combines both human input and the AI input irons out all the possibilities of having a computerized system that runs wild and places trades that are mathematically justified but do not fit the current market fundamentals and news.
The RoFx platform is simple to use and does not require setup
One thing you will be glad about after reading this ROFX.group review is that you are closer to a “hands free” investment channel that also has a sleek and simple platform. You can check up your account balance, see your profit history and contact the team of experts only with a few clicks. The platform does not need any downloading and as such, there is no difficult installation process involved. It may sound obvious but a lot of people do not find it easy to install and operate the platforms involved in traditional forex trading. Older systems had icons that needed a person to hoover the mouse over them for them to understand what they mean. The RoFx platform just needs someone to log onto the platform and click anything they want done quick.
No hidden costs and there is coverage
Believe it or not, traditional forex trading still has some costs involved whether you are making profits or not. People need to consider spreads and commissions meant for brokers. The kind of broker chosen also affects how much you pay in spreads and other hidden costs. Requotes have also been a sneaky method through which some brokers ensure that you do not profit out of quick scalp trades. With this service, investors do not get charged for depositing or withdrawing over the contract period and get very good prices for their bitcoin deposits.
You get the very best of protection for money you have deposited and enjoy loss coverage in case you are wondering what happens when the system makes a loss on that day. The service has a vast store of funds to cover for that negative profit for that day in case it occurs at all. Most of all, the money wallet in the service allows for easy transaction making with different deposit options such as bitcoin, bank transfer, VISA and Mastercard. You can make transactions from anywhere using any internet ready device.
submitted by ROFX_user to Daytrading [link] [comments]

What does No Slippage in Forex really mean? - Forex Markets Live

fintech #trading #algotrading #quantitative #quant #forex #fx #strategies #microstructure #marketmaking

What does No Slippage in Forex really mean?Slippage in Forex is when a non-limit order isn’t executed at the intended price. This is usually happening during times of high volatility and often during a news event. This would indicate a market condition and probably something that a Forex Broker has little control over. Then why do so many Forex Brokers make a claim they offer no slippage? No Slippage has become a marketable phrase used by brokers like ECN or STP.In the United States, Forex Brokers are prohibited from claiming no slippage unless they can demonstrate that all orders on its platform were executed at the original price and no requotes were given. US Brokers are also prohibited from making any price adjustments ever if they want to make this claim. The fact that regulators in the US saw how much these claims were being made and instituted this rule back in 2012.Some brokers are very transparent about slippage and the fact that they have little or no control over it. Peppers..... Continue reading at: https://forexmarketslive.com/what-does-no-slippage-in-forex-really-mean/
submitted by silahian to quant_hft [link] [comments]

ROFX - Review

ROFX - Review
https://preview.redd.it/gq5kmrjkfdn11.jpg?width=1200&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=19978f0a54d31140735d7ee27e906381d98d2c6a
Presuming that you have gone through all the basic requirements of what is needed to be a successful forex trader and found that you do not meet any, does that means it’s the end of your investment chances? Of course not because there is a service that lets even the novice and unrefined forex traders invest in the market without the slightest background in it. The ROFX.group for forex trading service will let you invest in this rewarding market with so much simplicity and flexibility that you do not need to do much other than wait for your profits. Beginners finally do not need to invest much mental work into choosing the right broker, installing the right software and trade. You finally do not need to begin the demo trading journey and learn all the details of money management, pair selection and correlation that beginner traders have to go through. This service just lets you invest a certain amount of money and have your profits remitted to you after a team of forex experts working with an AI system have done all the work. You know what that means? Your money grows in a stable and rewarding arrangement and still offers you a guarantee that your money will not shrink. The service offers profits of about 0.5% on average daily.
Artificial Intelligence in a different way
Artificial Intelligence aids with a lot of processes that would take a lot of time to do manually. Lately, these robots can even figure out some patterns that a human eye may have ignored or was just not aware of its existence and meaning. The ROFX.group robot is run by proven forex traders and other scientists who keep on updating its code with the newest trade-sensitive information to ensure that all clients only get the best of the market. You can go on with your business having the confidence that the team will work together to pick the optimal trades and leave out the potential bad eggs that have a high chance of ending up as losing trades.
AI is supervised by an experienced group of in-house forex traders
The AI system has been in operation for almost 10 years and it simply builds on the store of experience that the current team has had through the years. Having an operation style that combines both human input and the AI input irons out all the possibilities of having a computerized system that runs wild and places trades that are mathematically justified but do not fit the current market fundamentals and news.
The RoFx platform is simple to use and does not require setup
One thing you will be glad about after reading this ROFX.group review is that you are closer to a “hands free” investment channel that also has a sleek and simple platform. You can check up your account balance, see your profit history and contact the team of experts only with a few clicks. The platform does not need any downloading and as such, there is no difficult installation process involved. It may sound obvious but a lot of people do not find it easy to install and operate the platforms involved in traditional forex trading. Older systems had icons that needed a person to hoover the mouse over them for them to understand what they mean. The RoFx platform just needs someone to log onto the platform and click anything they want done quick.
No hidden costs and there is coverage
Believe it or not, traditional forex trading still has some costs involved whether you are making profits or not. People need to consider spreads and commissions meant for brokers. The kind of broker chosen also affects how much you pay in spreads and other hidden costs. Requotes have also been a sneaky method through which some brokers ensure that you do not profit out of quick scalp trades. With this service, investors do not get charged for depositing or withdrawing over the contract period and get very good prices for their bitcoin deposits.
You get the very best of protection for money you have deposited and enjoy loss coverage in case you are wondering what happens when the system makes a loss on that day. The service has a vast store of funds to cover for that negative profit for that day in case it occurs at all. Most of all, the money wallet in the service allows for easy transaction making with different deposit options such as bitcoin, bank transfer, VISA and Mastercard. You can make transactions from anywhere using any internet ready device.
submitted by ROFX_user to u/ROFX_user [link] [comments]

Current State of the Brokers

Still Operating
In Danger
Shutdown
No Annoucement
submitted by J2000_ca to Forex [link] [comments]

Forex Trading: Trading Consolidation/Breakout Patterns ... How to Play The Non Farm Payroll Forex Move on the EUR/USD

CFTC approved NFA’s rules on forex slippage and requoting. Jan 28 2012 By Forexbrokerz.com. According to the NFA's rules US Forex brokers must apply the slippage setting uniformly regardless of the direction the price has changed. The same applies to requoting - If the broker requotes prices when the market moves against it, it must requote prices when the market moves in its favor ... Starting from March 26, 2012 the new NFA rules about Price Slippage and Requotes come into effect. The rules are aimed to set a level playing field for brokers and traders, so that when slippages or requotes occur, they will no longer be "one-sided, mainly favoring brokers" (e.g. executed at the best price when the slippage (requote) favors brokers, and at the worst price when it favors ... 1) While some forex firms advertise real-time executable prices, their dealers may manually review each order you place and requote a worse price if the market is moving in your favor. In addition, their claims of 3-pip spreads routinely widen to 10 pips or more during fast-moving markets. A requote in the Forex world means that the broker you are dealing with is not able or willing to give you a trade based upon the price you entered. Generally, this happens in a fast-moving market, usually around the time of a big news announcement or some kind of a shock to the system. In essence, you decide to buy or sell a currency pair at a particular price and press the button to execute ... 5. REQUOTING. This is a big pitfall that many traders fell into before realizing. Low spreads and commissions do not mean much if the forex trading broker decides to "trick" you with requoting. Basically, what it means is that when you transact with a buy/sell call for a currency pair at a certain price, the broker requotes and charge you on the requoted price rather than what you see. Forex is characterized by sudden shifts of quotes against the background of economic and political news, and in 50% of such cases deviations will certainly not be in favor of traders. So, when the price goes down, losses start increasing rapidly and a broker doesn’t allow closing a transaction but sends requotes with new prices. Logically, in such situation a trader can accept any price ... A requote in the Forex world means that the broker you are dealing with is not able or willing to give you a trade based upon the price you entered. Generally this happens in a fast-moving market, usually around the time of a big news announcement or some kind of shock to the system. In essence, you decide to buy or sell a currency pair at a ...

[index] [1298] [24138] [17031] [12752] [338] [9727] [26208] [20861] [13430] [25403]

Forex Trading: Trading Consolidation/Breakout Patterns ...

Do understand that trading the non farm payroll or any expected news item like this is difficult as the spreads widen and there is requoting by some brokers. The best way to play is to wait until ... Innovation is Coming - http://tier1trading.com/ FOREX TRADING: A look at trading consolidating markets & breakout patterns such as triangles, wedges, flags a...

http://arab-binary-option.tiocrocanfounciacoa.ml